
View my articles
Mail me my articles
Talk Gaza : Flotilla facts
Melanie Phillips
Shariah Finance Watch
Australian Islamist Monitor - MultiFaith
Haifa diarist blog
Hitchens on Euston
Why Israel is at war
Lozowick Blog
NeoZionoid The NeoZionoiZeoN blog
Blank pages of the age
Silent Runnings
Jewish Issues watchdog
Discover more about Israel advocacy
Zionists the creation of Israel
Dissecting the Left
Paula says
Belmont Club
Perspectives on Israel - Zionists
Zionism & Israel Information Center
Zionism educational seminars
Christian dhimmitude
Forum on Mideast
Israel Blog - documents terror war against Israelis
Zionism on the web
RECOMMENDED: newsback News discussion community
RSS Feed software from CarP
Sderot media center
International law, Arab-Israeli conflict
Think-Israel
Abba Eban interview
The Big Lies
Shmloozing with terrorists
IDF ON YOUTUBE
Israel's contributions to the world
MEMRI
Mark Durie Blog
Air France promo of Israel, 1951
| Gaza Blockade | Diplomacy | Iran | History unfolding | Historic statements |
| Dhimmitude | Media imbalance | UN doings | Philosophy & Morality | US Politics |
| Terrorism | Australian Issues | Neo Anti Sem | Spengler | Videos |
Dear Senator,
My name is Leon Weinstein. I am an American. I am also Jewish. I was born in the Soviet Union, was fortunate to get out in 1974 and lived in Israel until my second immigration to the US in 1986. I have family in Israel, including my brother, parents, and my bellowed nephews. As you see I have a stock in Israel, and wouldn’t want this country to be bombed by nukes (or conventional rockets), annihilated or buldozered to the Mediterranean, all of the above being proposed by the esteemed leaders of practically all neighboring Israel nations. I am not a partial and neutral bystander. I am one very angry and concerned citizen and below I will try to explain to you why I am angry and concerned.
You might become our next President, Leader and Commander-in-Chief, but we the people know precious little about who you are, your ability to withstand pressure, your philosophy, sympathies and preferences, your experience and your judgment. During your recent campaigning we hear from you many wonderful words like “unification of America”, “no more blue or red states”, “help to humanity”, “care for those that need care”, and I applaud those words. If your words are supported by your past actions, then you might be the man for the job. If your words contradict or are unsupported by what you did before the Presidential race, then you are not what you say you are, right? In order to find that out I attempted to examine whom you hang out with, what words you and your friends were saying in private and in public and how all that can affect our lives.
First, I decided to look who is endorsing you (according to the information that can be found on Internet), who likes where you stand on issues. I found among others a scaring host of anti-Semitic and anti-Israeli people and organizations:
- Louis Farrakhan (Nation of Islam Leader, racist, anti-Semite)
- Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades (Islamic Terror Organization)
- Raila Odinga (Fundamental Islamic Candidate, Kenya, some say he is your cousin)
- Daniel Ortega (Marxist Sandinista Leader, Nicaragua)
- Raul Castro (Hard-line Communist Leader, Cuba)
- Socialist Party USA (Marxist Political Party)
- The New Black Panther Party (Black Militant Organization)
- Hamas Terrorist Organization (Islamic Terrorist Organization).
I was really surprised to find so many American enemies routing for you (Hamas, Sandinistas, Cuban Marxists), but what really frightened me was that there is a well-organized effort on the Middle East to call American voters at random asking them to vote for Obama. Who pays them for the expensive phone calls to America? Who trained them what to say and who gave them names and phone numbers of the American voters? This was reported by Al Jazeera: “After studying Obama’s campaign manifesto I thought this is a man that’s capable of change inside of America.” said one of pro-Obama Middle Eastern organizers.
“But may be” I was arguing with myself, “I can’t blame you for that, since you didn’t ask for their endorsements or their help? You may be even do not know about it, or do you? On the other hand if our enemies (Hamas, Sandinistas, Cuban Marxists) love you so much, may be it says something about your agenda?”
Enough about those that like you. Let’s look at whom you like, whom you planning to bring to the White House to govern America. You invited Zbigniew Brzezinski to become your chief political advisor. Brzezinski signed a letter demanding dialogue with Hamas, whose charter calls for Israel’s destruction. He has also an interesting view on Communism that I am afraid you may share: “Communism has the intellectually tantalizing possibility that for the world at large. It was … a blessing in disguise”. WOW! “Blessing in disguise?” Half of my family was murdered in Gulags. My beloved grandfather died after a stroke at the KGB headquarters.
Your advisor on nuclear policies Joseph Cirincione in response to reports that the site in Syria that Israel bombed was a potential nuclear facility being established with the help of North Korea, said that the reports were the product of two nefarious, agenda-driven groups: (1) Bush administration hardliners seeking to derail "the U.S.-North Korean agreement" and (2) Israelis who "want to thwart any dialogue between the U.S. and Syria." WOW again!
Your financial backer billionaire George Soros repeatedly says in his speeches: “The main obstacle to a stable and just world order is the United States.” How many times in one letter I can repeat WOW! Another obstacle he considers Israel. If you have an obstacle on your way, you remove it, right? Do you share the same ideology that Soros professes? As a matter of fact, looks like your wife does. Soros is the power behind moveon.org, and this is he who puts money in your campaign coffins. In the old world we had a saying, “he who dines the girl, is dances her as well”. What dance you promised Soros?
"The world powers established this filthy bacteria, the Zionist regime, which is lashing out at the nations in the region like a wild beast."- this is what President of Iran Ahmadinejad says of Israel. He consistently calls for destruction of Israel and the “Big Satan”, the United States. Iran harbors and finances terrorists around the globe. At the same time your most senior military adviser retired Gen. Merrill McPeak says President Bush and Israel is to blame for Iran's bad behavior: “It was us that insulted them by including them in the 'axis of evil' and making sure they understood we didn't like them very much. That drove us apart," says McPeak and continues: "Obama's idea is, why not talk to them. Why not see if there isn't some common ground. Certainly, the fight against al Qaeda would be one of them."
Dear Senator, hate of Israel would also be a good common ground with Iran, Hesbollah and Hamas. I remember the overwhelming joy on the Iranian and Palestinian streets when they heard about 9/11. Same joy I recall when Hezbollah dragged on the streets of Gaza killed Israeli soldiers in front of TV cameras. The same joy they experienced when masked terrorists beheaded Americans and many other infidels they kidnap, torture and videotape their murders.
Simon Malley, another of your foreign policy advisors loathes Israel. The anti-Israel activism became a crusade for him. He spent countless hours with Yasser Arafat and became a close friend of Arafat. He was, according to Daniel Pipes, a sympathizer of the Palestinian Liberation Organization --- and this was when it was at the height of its terrorism wave against the West. His efforts were so damaging to France that President Valerie d'Estaing expelled him from the country. Now you want him to give you an advice regarding Middle East and relations with Israel.
I can go on and on. My big question to you is – usually we surround ourselves with like-minded people. Didn’t you notice that all those people quite contradicting your public speeches? Or may be they express your hidden thoughts and agenda?
During an ABC interview Stephanopoulos asked you: “So you would extend our deterrent to Israel?” your answer was: “As I said before, I think it is very important that Iran understands that an attack on Israel, is an attack on our strongest ally in the region, one that we -- one whose security, we consider paramount. And that would be an act of aggression that we would -- that I would consider an attack that is unacceptable. And the United States would take appropriate action."
It is important to notice that you didn’t say, “We will come after them and will respond in full force”. Dear Senator – what is this “appropriate action” of yours? We already know that your mentors Reverend Wright and socialist billionaire Soros think that the US and Israel stand in a way to the “progress”. May be the appropriate action, as you and your team understand it will be to tell Iranians “Good job, guys”?
Israel is an American alley that brings to the relations its fair share. I want you to read exerts from two articles written by Ambassador (ret.) Yoram Ettinger, who is an expert on U.S. Middle East policy:
Former secretary of state and NATO supreme commander Gen. (ret.) Alexander Haig refers to Israel as the largest, most cost-effective combat-experienced U.S. aircraft carrier – one that does not require American personnel, cannot be sunk and is located in a region critical to U.S. national security interests. In 1967, Israel defeated a pro-Soviet Egypt/Syria axis. In 1970, Israel forced the rollback of an invasion by pro-Soviet Syria of pro-U.S. Jordan, preventing a pro-Soviet Domino Effect in the Persian Gulf. In 1981, Israel destroyed Iraq’s nuclear reactor, enabling the U.S. to proceed with conventional military options in its wars against Saddam Hussein. In 1982, Israel destroyed Syrian-operated Soviet surface-to-air missile batteries, which were considered impregnable. Israeli-developed unmanned aerial vehicles have been employed by U.S. Marines in Afghanistan and Iraq, providing otherwise unattainable intelligence and preempting terrorist strikes. The Israeli-developed Lightning Pod navigation guidance system eliminated Al-Zarqawi, the arch Al-Qaeda terrorist. Absent Israel and its contribution to U.S. national security, Washington would have to deploy, to the eastern flank of the Mediterranean, aircraft carriers and tens of thousands of servicemen, costing scores of billions of dollars annually.
Dear Senator, we all would want to hear you saying words that in uncertain terms will tell our enemies that you are not their friend, that you stand and will stand for our country and for the principals of the founding fathers of our country. How about repeating the pledge that Professor Wichman of Mechanical Engineering at MSU wrote to a group of “outraged by Jewish behavior” Muslim students in his University:
I (Barack Hussein Obama) will stand firmly against beheadings of civilians, cowardly attacks on public buildings, suicide murders, murders of Catholic priests (the latest in Turkey), burnings of Christian churches, the continued persecution of Coptic Christians in Egypt, the imposition of Sharia law on non-Muslims, the rapes of Scandinavian girls and women (called 'whores' in extreme Muslim culture), the murder of film directors in Holland, and the rioting and looting in Paris France. This is what offends me, and many, many of my fellow Americans. This shall be stopped and stopped immediately. I will not tolerate it on my watch. As a US President I will stand firm to stop this aggressive, brutal, and uncivilized behavior. I will defend our allies including Israel, and will destroy any one who will try to destroy them. Amen!
Looks like you are not going to do it. This will make your Far Left friends angry with you. You will hide behind words and smiles and half-truths. Exactly as you were hiding your controversial pastor in the basement of the building before you announced your bid for the US presidency.
Dear Senator, I received the below written text by email. I do not know the sender, but I agree with him/her hundred percent. And I want you and your sponsors, supporters and advisors to read it as well:
Any nation or culture that tried to mess around with the nation of Israel was destroyed -- while we Jews kept going! Egypt? Anyone knows where their empire disappeared to? Greeks? Alexander of Macedonia? The Romans? Does anyone today speak Latin? The Third Reich? Anyone heard any news about it lately? And look at us, the Nation from the Bible, from Slavery in Egypt. We are still here, speaking the same language! Do not even think about positioning the United States of America against Israel and Jews.
Sincerely,
Leon A.Weinstein
Los Angeles, CA
PS I can’t imagine being a Jew and voting Obama. I can’t imagine being an Israeli supporter and voting Obama either. I can’t imagine voting Obama period.
Oscar-winning director Oliver Stone in an interview decried what he called the Jewish lobby's control over Washington's foreign policy and said that Hitler's actions should be put "into context."
A day after Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said he would not extend a West Bank building freeze, violence broke out in an outpost there following the demolition of an illegally built home.
A former American spy chief says the path to U.S. military action against Iran is inescapable.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu slammed the team named by the United Nations Human Rights Council to investigate the Turkish flotilla incident.
New Zealand's Jewish community is mounting a legal case against the country's new law banning kosher slaughter.
The Obama administration will allow the PLO office in Washington to fly the Palestinian flag and assume the title of "delegation."
The elected leader of Australian Jewry blasted his Christian counterpart over an "ill-considered" resolution asking churches to boycott goods produced by West Bank Jews.
Yemen's Supreme Court has upheld the death sentence of a Yemeni man who killed a Jewish fellow citizen after demanding that he convert.
Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak is returning to Washington to coordinate ways to isolate Iran.
Vandals painted red swastikas on the walls of the Jewish Museum of Greece in Athens.
Haredi Orthodox youth are being blamed for a massive fire near Jerusalem that nearly led to the evacuation of Hadassah Hospital.
U.S. Rep. Jan Schakowsky (D-Ill.) called on her opponent in their congressional election to stop writing for Andrew Breitbart's conservative website.
The president of Egypt's Jewish community allegedly has fled the country after being convicted of fraud and ordered to prison.
Israel lost to Turkey in the Euroleague women's volleyball bronze medal game in an empty arena amid tight security.
A Chabad rabbi has become the first rabbi since World War II to join the Canadian armed forces full time.
Israeli airstrikes reportedly destroyed a weapons manufacturing site and two smuggling tunnels in the Gaza Strip.
A firecracker exploded on the steps of the synagogue in Malmo, Sweden, a day after a bomb threat was taped to the building.
Israel's Cabinet agreed to send a group of police officers to Haiti to maintain public order.
A Netanya man was arrested for murdering his three young children.
Ahead of midterm elections, a Democratic leader distributed talking points to fellow House Democrats stressing support for Israel by President Obama and the party.
Two Jewish schools were ranked among the best high schools in Brazil.
The Palestinian Authority has granted travel documents and honorary citizenship to Irish anti-Israel activists who participated in a Gaza aid flotilla.
Read it again. You made too many mistakes to waste any time addressing them. If you are going to comment on something make sure your comments are pursuant to what has been said and not what you think was meant by what was said. When you are going to call someone an idiot make sure that description doesn't apply to you. It is best not to try to be insulting in the first place and in the second place to have an honest exchange of ideas and try to understand something which might be new to you because it is the truth. I realize it is a novel and unusual concept but truth generally works. Hank Roth
Posted on 2008-07-02 18:23:05 GMT
Mr Weinstein, I'm sad for your losses experienced under the former rulers of the Soviet Union, nothing can ever make up for those kinds of losses. My own family, as did many Jewish families, lost huge percentages under various totalitarian regimes in Western & Eastern Europe, in the Middle East... all of which we are well versed in, even if we personally didn't experience the trauma. However, I have to say that in spite of your experiences, I cannot read the sort of idiocy you perpetuate in your piece. You mention so many people and thereby generate a guilt by association arrangement with them and Barack Obama. This was the kind of technique which the Soviet era Police used to make innocent people appear guilty and somehow the technique is therefore appropriate for you to use. Barack Obama was a community activist on the South Side of Chicago. How do you think for a moment that it would have been possible for him to have helped to advance the cause of African Americans in so many blighted communities, without having become at very least cordial with people such as Louis Farrakhan, leader of The Nation of Islam? I have no respect on a political level for this man, however his organisation has done extraordinary work with his core community and nothing said about he and his ties to oppressive Middle eastern despots such as Ghaddafi can minimise his work in his neighbourhood. Your next Laundry list of political figures simply shows your refusal to accept that not all those to the left of the spectrum are not all out to establish Gulags any more than all Capitalists are out to enslave the Workers of the world. Then to add a Kenyan Muslim and add the slanderous comment that " ...Some say he's your cousin" - is exactly like saying that you may well be related to Joseph Stalin - well, you are from the same country aren't you and it was always said that he was a Jew trying to deny his Jewish identity. Seriously, all this information you at least have the good grace to credit your information source as the internet. The internet is a wonderful place to seek general information, but given the amount of acrimony regarding this Presidential Candidate, hardly a serious source of factual information! I mean Raul Castro, a hard-line communist leader? If he's so hardline, why has he been so open to foreign investment in Cuba? Why are Cubans permitted to have mobile phones? Start their own businesses? For all that Cuba is a failed experiment in Communism, at least it has universal health care. Whether you like the mans position or not, Obama is trying to take on advisors with serious credentials that lend gravitas to their information. When I do an internet search on Brzezinski, I'll venture a guess that he has more work on Political Science and Foreign Affairs than you do. As for the comment that outsiders might see a change of Government leading to a change of attitude on the part of US foreign Affairs... well, many would say about time! How long is the US government going to use fear as a method of exerting control over its own citizens? Mr Weinstein, the reason you wouldn't have been able to get a Visa to live in the US in the mid 70's was the same fear of foreigners that your current President has exploited to his own ends. You mention Daniel Pipes and suggest that he is a pro PLO supporter. What utter rubbish! I have never been aware, in the several times I've heard Daniel Pipes speak and in the papers he has written of anything other than railing against Middle Eastern fundamentalism. As for Obama's backer, George Soros, I'm fairly certain that most of Senators current contributors are everyday Americans who understand that an attitude of wanting to include and not exclude, a desire to alter the status quo so that someone speaks for the average citizen not the 1% of Americans who have any real sway with the current administration. Yes, the Senator my be a little short on hard positioning statements, although I'd rather those be formalised over the course of the next several months. If you'd prefer to have a president who plays on your seemingly boundless fear of the foreigner, who makes it possible to run America into the ground economically, morally, philosophically and politically - then have at it. Just don't base it on what you can glean from the undocumented sources of the Internet. Perhaps you might also like to leave some of that Dark Russian sense of the world behind and embrace the positive possibilities of the US and what it is capable of when lead with responsibility and courage.
Posted
by Luke Caldwell on 2008-06-06 09:07:37 GMT